Sunday, April 4, 2010

Latency & Human Response Time in current and future games

I'm still surprised at how many gamers and even developers aren't aware that typical games today have total response latencies ranging anywhere from 60-200ms. We tend to think of latencies in terms of pings and the notion that the response time or 'ping' from a computer or a console five feet away can be comparable to the ping of a server a continent away is something of an unnatural notion.

Yet even though it seems odd, its true.

I just read through "
Console Gaming: The Lag Factor", a recent blog article on EuroGamer which follows up on Mick West's original Gamasutra article that pioneered measuring the actual response times of games using a high speed digital camera. For background, I earlier wrote a GDM article (Gaming in the Cloud) that referenced that data and showed how remotely rendered games running in the cloud have the potential to at least match the latency of local console games, primarily by running at a higher FPS.

The eurogamer article alludes to this idea:

In-game latency, or the level of response in our controls, is one of the most crucial elements in game-making, not just in the here and now, but for the future too. It's fair to say that players today have become conditioned to what the truly hardcore PC gamers would consider to be almost unacceptably high levels of latency to the point where cloud gaming services such as OnLive and Gaikai rely heavily upon it.

The average videogame runs at 30FPS, and appears to have an average lag in the region of 133ms. On top of that is additional delay from the display itself, bringing the overall latency to around 166ms. Assuming that the most ultra-PC gaming set-up has a latency less than one third of that, this is good news for cloud gaming in that there's a good 80ms or so window for game video to be transmitted from client to server


Its really interesting to me that the author assumes that "ultra-PC" gaming set up has a latency less than one third of a console - even though the general model developed in the article posits that their is no fundamental difference between PCs and consoles in terms of latency - other than framerate.

In general, the article shows that games have inherent delay measured in frames - the minimum seems to be about 3 frames of delay, but can go up to 5 for some games. The total delay in time units is simply N/F, the number of frames of delay over the frame rate. A simple low-delay app will typically have the minimum delay - about 3, which maps to around 50ms running at 60fps and 100ms at 30fps.


There is no fundemental difference between consoles and PC's in this regard other than framerate - the PC version of a game running at 60fps will have the same latency as its console sibling running at 60fps. Of course, take a 30fps console game and run it at 60fps and you halve the latency - and yes this exactly what cloud gaming services can exploit.


The eurogamer article was able to actually measure just that - proving this model with some real world data. The author was able to use the vsync feature in bioshock to measure the response difference between 59fps and 30fps, and as expected, the 59fps had just about half the latency.

The other assertion of the article - or rather the whole point of the article - was that low response times are really important for the 'feel' of a game. So I'd like to delve into this in greater detail. As a side note though, the fact that delay needs to be measured for most games to make any sort of guess about its response time tells you something.

Firstly, on the upper end of the spectrum, developers and gamers know from 1st hand experience that there definitely is an upper window to tolerable latency, although it depends on the user action. For most games, controlling the camera with a joypad or mouse feels responsive with a latency of up to 150ms. You might think that the mouse control would be considerably more demanding in this regard, but the data does not back that up - I assert that PC games running at 30fps have latencies in the same 133-150ms window as 30fps console games, and are quite playable at that fps (and some have even shipped capped at 30fps).


There is a legitimate reason for a PC gamer to try to minimize their system latency as much as possible for competitive multiplayer gaming, especially twitch shooters like counterstrike. A system running with vsync off at 100fps might have latencies under 50ms and will give you a considerable advantage over an opponent running at 30fps with 133-150ms of base system latency - no doubt about that.


But what I'm asserting is that most gamers will barely - if at all - be able to notice the difference of delay times under 100ms in typical scenarios in FPS and action games - whether using a gamepad or mouse and keyboard. As the delay times exceed some threshold they become increasingly noticeable - 200ms of delay is noticeable to most users, and 300ms becomes unplayable. That being said, variation in the delay is much more noticeable. The difference between a perfectly consistent 30fps and 60fps is difficult to perceive, but an inconsistent 30fps is quite noticeable - the spike or changes in response time from frame to frame themselves are neurologically relevant and quite detectable. This is why console developers spend a good deal of time to optimize the spike frames and hit a smooth 30fps.

There is however a class of actions that do have a significantly lower latency threshold - the simple action of moving a mouse cursor around on the screen! Here I have some 1st hand data. A graphics app which renders its own cursor, has little buffering and runs at 60fps will have about 3 frames or about 50ms of lag, and at that low level of delay the cursor feels responsive. However if you take that same app and slow it down to 30fps, or even add just a few more frames of latency at 60fps the cursor suddenly seems to lag behind. The typical solution is to use the hardware cursor feature which short circuits the whole rendering pipeline and provides a direct fast path to pipe mouse data to the display - which seems to be under 50ms. For the low-latency app running at 60fps, the hardware cursor isn't necessary, but it becomes suddenly important at some threshold around 70-90ms.

I think that this is the real absolute lower limit of human ability to perceive delay.

Why is there such a fundamental limit? In short: the limitations of the brain.

Ponder for a second what it actually means for the brain to notice delay in a system. The user initiates an action and sometime later this results in a response, and if that response is detected as late, the user will notice delay. Somewhere, a circuit (or potentially circuits, but for our purposes this doesn't matter) in the brain makes a decision to initiate an action, this message must then propagate down to muscles in the hand where it then enters the game system through the input device. Meanwhile in the brain, the decision circuit must also send messages to the visual circuits of the form "I have initiated action and am expecting a response - please look for this and notify me immediately on detection". Its easier to imagine the brain as a centralized system like a single CPU, but it is in fact the exact opposite - massively distributed - a network really on the scale of the internet itself - and curiously for our discussion, with latencies comparable to the internet itself.

Neurons can fire only as fast as about 10ms typically, perhaps as quickly as 5ms in some regions. The fastest neural conduits - myelinated fiber - can send signals from the brain to the fingertip (one way) in about 20ms. So now imagine using these slow components to build a circuit that could detect a timing delay in as quickly as 60ms.

Lets start with the example of firing a gun. At a minimum, we have some computation to decide to fire, and once this happens the message can be sent down to the fingertip to pull the trigger and start the process. At the same time, for the brain to figure out if the gun actually fired in time, the message must also be sent down to the visual circuits, where the visual circuits must process the visual input stream and determine if the expected response exists (a firing gun), this information can then be sent to some higher circuit which can then compute whether the visual response (gun firing response pattern exists or not at this moment in time) matches the action initiated (the brain sent a firing signal to the finger at this moment in time).

Built out of slow 10ms neurons, this circuit is obviously going to have alot of delay of its own which is going to place some limits its response time and ability to detect delay. Thinking of the basic neuron firing system as the 'clock rate' and the brain as a giant computer (which it is in the abstract sense), it appears that the brain can compute some of these quick responses in as little as around a dozen 'clock cycles'. This is pretty remarkable, even given that the brain has trillions of parallel circuits. But anyway, the brain could detect even instantaneous responses if it had the equivalent of video buffering. In other words, if the brain could compensate for its own delay, it could detect delays in the firing response on timescales shorter than its own response time. For this to happen though, the incoming visual data would need to be buffered in some form. The visual circuits, instead of being instructed to signal upon detection of a firing gun, could be instructed to search for a gun firing X ms in the past. However, to do this they would need some temporal history - the equivalent of a video buffer. There's reasons to believe some type of buffering does exist in the brain, but with limitations - its nothing like a computer video buffer.

The other limitation to the brain's ability to detect delays is the firing times of neurons themselves which make it difficult to detect timings on scales approaching the neuron firing rate.
But getting back to the visual circuits, the brain did not evolve to detect lag in video games or other systems. Just because its theoretically possible that a neural circuit built out of relatively slow components could detect fact responses by compensating for its own processing delay does not mean that the brain actually does this. The quick 'twitch' circuits we are talking about evolved to make rapid decisions - things like: detect creature, identify as prey or predator, and initiate flight or fight. These quick responses involve rapid pattern recognition, classification, and decision making, all in real-time. However, the quick response system is not especially concerned with detecting exactly when an event occurred, its optimized for the problem of reacting to events rapidly and correctly. Detecting if your body muscles reacted to the run command at the right time is not the primary function of these circuits - it is to detect the predator threat and initiate the correct run response rapidly. The insight and assertion I'm going to make is that our ability to detect delays in other systems (such as video games) is only as good as our brain's own quick response time - because it uses the same circuits. Psychological tests show the measured response time is around ~200ms for many general tasks, probably getting a little lower for game-like tasks with training. A lower bound of around 100-150ms for complex actions like firing guns and moving cameras seems reasonable for experienced players.

For moving a mouse cursor, the response time appears to be lower, perhaps 60-90ms. From this brain model, we can expect that for a few reasons. Firstly, the mouse cursor is very simple and very small, and once the visual system is tracking it we can expect that detecting changes in its motions (to verify that its moving as intended) is computationally simple and can be performed in the minimal number of steps. Detecting that the entire scene moved in the correct direction, or that the gun is in its firing animation state are far more complex pattern recognition tasks, and we can expect they would take more steps. So detecting mouse motion represents the simplest and fastest type of visual pattern recognition.

There is another factor at work here as well: rapid eye cascades. The visual system actually directs the eye muscles on frame by frame time scales that we don't consciously perceive. When recognizing a face, you may you think you are looking at someone right in the eye, but if you watched a high res video feed of yourself and zoomed in on your eyes in slow motion, you'd see that your eyes are actually making many rapid jumps - leaping from the eyebrow to the lips to the nose and so on. Presumably when moving around a mouse cursor, some of these eye cascades are directed to predicted positions of the mouse to make it easy for the visual system to detect its motion (and thus detect if its lagging).

So in summary, experimental data (from both games and psychological research) leads us to expect that the threshold for human delay detection is around:

300ms> games become unpleasant, even unplayable
200ms> delay becomes palpable
100-150ms - limit of delay detection for full scene actions - camera panning and so on
50-60ms - absolute limit of delay detection - small object tracking - mouse cursors

Delay is a strongly non-linear phenomena, undetectable beyond certain threshold and then ramping up to annoying and then deal breaking soon after. Its not a phenomenon where less is always better. Less beyond a certain point doesn't matter from a user experience point of view. (of course, for competitive twitch gaming, having less delay is definitely advantageous even when you can't notice it - but this isn't relevant for console type systems where everyone has the same delay)

So getting back to the earlier section of this post, if we run a game on a remote pc, what can we expect the total delay to be?

The cloud system has several additional components that can add delay on top of the game itself: video compression, the network, and the client which decompresses the video feed.

Without getting into specifics, what can we roughly expect? Well, even a simple client which just decompresses video is likely to exhibit the typical minimum of roughly 3 frames of lag. Lets assume the video compression can be done in a single frame and the network and buffering adds another, we are looking then at roughly 5 frames of additional lag with a low ping to the server - with some obvious areas that could be trimmed further.

If everything is running at 60, a low latency game (3 frames of internal lag), might exhibit around 8/60 or 133ms of latency, and a higher latency game (5 frames of internal lag), might exhibit 10/60 or 166ms of latency. So it seems reasonable to expect that games running at 60fps remotely can have latencies similar to local games running at 30fps. Ping to the server then does not represent even the majority of the lag, but obviously can push the total delay into the unplayable as the ping grows - and naturally every frame of delay saved allows the game to be playable at the same quality at increasingly greater distances from the server.

What are the next obvious areas of improvement? You could squeeze and save additional frames here and there (the client perhaps could be optimized down to 2 frames of delay - something of a lower limit though), but the easiest way to further lower the latency is just to double the FPS again.

120 fps may seem like alot, but it also happens to be a sort of requirement for 3D gaming, and is the direction that all new displays are moving. At 120fps, the base lag in such an example would be around 8/120 to 10/120, or around 66ms to 83ms of latency, comparable to 60fps console games running locally. This also hints that a remotely rendered mouse cursor would be viable at such high FPS. At 120fps, you could have a ping as high as 100ms and still get an experience comparable to a local console .

This leads to some interesting rendering directions if you start designing for 120fps and 3D, instead of the 30fps games are typically designed for now. The obvious optimization for 120fps and 3D is to take advantage of the greater inter-frame coherence. Reusing shading, shadowing, lighting and all that jazz from frame to frame has proportionately greater advantage at high FPS as the scene will change proportionately less between frames. Likewise, the video compression work and bitrate scales sublinearly, and actually increases surprisingly slowly as you double the framerate.



155 comments:

Arseny Kapoulkine said...

I have a question regarding latency that was haunting me for some time since I've read the article, perhaps you know the answer?

The article says that the absolute minimum latency for a 60 fps game is 3 frames, and that most 60 fps games have 4 frame latency.

I'm guessing the usual setup is as follows:
- at start of frame N, get input from the gamepad
- at frame N, perform state updates according to gamepad input and generate command buffer for GPU
- at frame N+1, GPU renders the frame
- at frame N+2, TV "displays" the image - i.e. is processing it
- at end of frame N+2, TV finally "shows" the image, meaning that the user can see it

That's 3 full frames of latency from the point of grabbing data from gamepad (assuming good TV?). I'm assuming PS3 XMB processes the input and generates the corresponding command buffer quickly so that GPU can render it immediately and get it ready in the same frame, which makes 2 full frames of latency from the same point.

Does this mean that the *actual* latency is not 4 frames but somewhere in the middle between 3 and 4 frames, if we account for the fact that the user likely pressed the gamepad button between frame boundaries (making mean latency 3.5)? Or is there an additional latency for key press to reach the console hardware/software?

Jake Cannell said...

Arseny - the minimum 3 frames of latency that appears from measurements is an approximation.

I think it comes from 1 frame to process the simulation on the CPU, 1 frame to render into the backbuffer, and 1 frame to transmit the frontbuffer to the display.

Rewording your frame counting a bit: Looking at it counting down, at any one point in time, if frame N is the current immediate frame for user input, then the CPU is simulating frame N-1, the GPU is rendering N-2 into the backbuffer, and frame N-3 is being displayed. This assumes the front buffer is being scanned immediately as CRT's do, but I think most LCD displays store at least a buffer - so really its probably N-3 is being transmitted over DVI and N-4 or even higher is being displayed. So CRT's are often used as the measurement reference for latency as they directly display the front buffer immediately.

If you look at it in more extreme detail, there is definitely some input latency, and discrete events like button presses can come in at any time, although they are often sampled altogether only at the beginning of the frame (effectively collecting all buffered inputs that occurred over the last frame).

Arseny Kapoulkine said...

Thanks, that clears things up for me.

Unknown said...

This was a very interesting read, but I have doubts about the validity of the 3 frame generalization. There's no reason that the non-rendering parts of a game can't run at a higher frame rate than the graphical representation of the game state. IIRC games like Forza run at very high simulation frame rates (over 120), and the display is updated separately. In that case the theoretical limit would be one frame with a superpowered computer and display that can compute the next frame's display in under one frame. I'm sure in the real world there are a few different chips that the data passes through (including the display), but even then the limitation would be the data transfer rate, which could feasibly be well under one frame with crazy hardware.

As long as you can generate a view of your internal model in under one frame there is no reason you can't theoretically have a 1-frame "lag" (quotes because even if you had no processing time there would be one frame of delay). There is no reason to keep transfer buffers limited to the display frame rate.

Unknown said...

MP Vyapam PAHUNT Model Answer (PDF) 2016 – vyapam.nic.in

SSC 10th Class New Syllabus for TS & AP State, PDF 2016

Unknown said...

Thanks for information. Are your know SSC Result 2016 and what is new information about Bangladesh Result Update For More information visit http://diplomabd.com/ssc-result-2016/ and know mor about SSC Result 2016

Engineering Friend said...

Thanks Everybody.For know about SSC Result 2016 Click this link and Know the latest SSC Result 2016 Information. By flowing us on facebook and other

Kamal Badra said...

Such a great information
Latest News ..Check MP Vyapam Sub Engineer Notification 2017 and MP Vyapam Sub Engineer Previous Papers 2017 here. Now you can also check the MP Vyapam Jail Prahari Admit Card2017 .
The Posta Circle Result now available.
TN Postal Circle GDS Result 2017
Assam Postal Circle GDS Result 2017
Delhi Postal Circle GDS Result 2017

Panharith said...

It very interesting.





Goldenslot

Unknown said...

EDU JOBS Circular- your path to unlimited success.

Unknown said...

Greetings, There's no doubt that your site could possibly be having internet browser compatibility problems. Whenever I look at your site in Safari, it looks fine however when opening in IE, it's got some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Besides that, fantastic site!
https://pcgamesdownloadhub.com/grand-theft-auto-v-pc-free-download/

Clipping path service said...

Design Service Asia Best Clipping Path Service Provider Company. We are
provide all type image editing and graphics design. Our skilled Graphic
Designer is ready for 24 hours.
Your professional Clipping Path Service for web stores & Ecommerce Business.
https://designserviceasia.com/

WORLD NEWS said...

Clipping path service is best of kind of image editing Process. where we select a important allocation of an image and cut the important part.Clipping path We can delete the background or change background color to make it more alluring.

Hijab $X Ruby said...

Thanks to you for sharing tons of information with us. The blog is very easy to read and understand. You can also write about DOWNLOAD BEST ANDROID APPS, FREE VPN, EMULATOR GAMES FOR PC.

William Alex said...

many many thanks to you for sharing tons of information with us.We are providing background removal service for your business.
Are you professional photographers, photography agencies, eCommerce retailers? If so Orbit Graphics is the right co-partner for your eCommerce product photo editing solutions including background removal service.

Shariful said...

Lokaqq adalah Situs Poker Dan Dominoqq Terbaru Dan Terpercaya paling bagus dan terbesar di asia juga sebagai website penyedia game poker online terbaik tahun 2020 adu q terpercaya

saimon mir said...

Your product photos determine the way buyers perceive your brand out there. So, high-quality ECommerce Photo Editing Services.

bise pakistan said...

Gujranwala Board is one of the nine sheets working under Punjab Examination Commission. These specialists are answerable for the straightforward and legitimacy based aftereffects of ninth Class. Consistently the outcomes are declared following three months of the tests, so the normal date of ninth class results is 19 August 2020. BISE Federal Board Intermediate Supplementary Result 2020 At the point when the specialists will proclaim the outcome, it will be distributed here immediately on the specific declaration date.Date of ninth class result 2020 by Gujranwala Board

mahfuz billah said...

Thanks for your great info about the topic of blog commenting.it is very good information,¶óÀ̺êÄ«Áö³ë I know how to comment blog Coin Casino

bise pakistan said...

BISE Rawalpindi eleventh class tests will be held in May and June. The tests start in May and end in the long stretch of June. The Rawalpindi load up set aside some effort for the accumulation of the outcome and checking of the papers. The outcome is declared following three months. The consequence of eleventh class is reported in August or September. Understudies can see the outcomes and other notice on our site. BISE Rawalpindi Board eleventh class result 2020

The BISE Rawalpindi Board eleventh class result 2020 will be declared following 3 months of the tests

bise pakistan said...

The BISE Rawalpindi Board twelfth class result 2020 will be reported following 3 months of the tests. Check our site Bise Pakistan to check BISE Rawalpindi Board twelfth class result 2020.
BISE Rawalpindi twelth class result 2020
Stay in contact with our site to see the notice about the twelfth class tests and different news.

SarkariNaukriHona Team said...

listoutnow.com Unique content keep going !

bise pakistan said...

Territory Swat and District Saidu Sharif are related with BISE Swat and dependably countless of these zones show up in the last, most critical preliminary of the Board.
BISE Swat was set up in the year 1990 and the basic parts of the Board are to frame the tests in a reasonable manner and enable the understudies with the most recent updates and huge material.
Swat Board SSC Part 1 Result

For 2020, the Matric Part I and Part II are managed in March and April autonomously. ninth Class Result 2020 BISE Swat Board will be announced soon for Matric.

bise pakistan said...

The Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education Sukkur conducts the trial of tenth class in the long stretch of March every year and articulates the aftereffect of the proportionate in the time of July, The load up is prepared to report the BISE Sukkur Board tenth Class Result 2020 on fifteenth of July this year.
Matric Result 2020 Sukkur Board
BISE Sukkur Board drives the optional and higher auxiliary level evaluation. In all probability, this is the best work under the supervision of Board of Intermediate and Secondary preparing Sukkur. In this way, it expect a major activity in the improvement of Pakistan's informative structure. In any case, Students can tail us and get the latest updates of Sukkur Board tenth Class Result 2020 at this page after the official explanation.

SarkariNaukriHona Team said...

listoutnow.com you are consistently doing good !

Unknown said...

ARE YOU LOOKING FOR INVESTOR, MONEY LENDER, PERSONAL LOAN, BUSINESS LOAN, IMPORT FUND, EXPORT FUND, TRADE FINANCE, PROJECT FINANCE, PROJECT FUND, STARTUP FUND, MT760 BG/SBLC LEASE OR SALE TO START A NEW BUSINESS OR TO EXPAND EXISTING BUSINESS FROM HONGKONG, CHINA, INDIA, USA, UNITED KINGDOM, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES OR ANYWHERE WORLDWIDE???
PLEASE APPLY THROUGH EMAIL : GLOBALFINANCELTDHK@GMAIL.COM

G-win88 said...

ยินดีต้อนรับสู่ g-win88.com เกมคาสิโนออนไลน์อันดับ 1 ที่ดีที่สุดในประเทศไทยและเอเชีย!

⮚ รับโบนัสฟรี 100% สำหรับสมาชิกใหม่
⮚ โปรโมชั่น แทงบอลออนไลน์ รับค่าคอม x3
⮚ โปรโมชั่น ลูกค่าบาคาร่า รับคืนยอดเสีย ฟรีๆ 10%

╔══════════════════╗
♛สมัครวันนี้เลย ADD LINE : https://lin.ee/1ZdZara
☎️Call Center บริการตลอด 24 ชม. 0929553889
💋💋รับสิทธิ์ ฟรี!! จำนวนจำกัด💋💋
╚══════════════════╝

London Construct Ltd said...

Thanks for sharing this post. I will like your content idea it's very awesome to read and understand. looking forward to your next post. London Construct Ltd are top-rated among home improvement company in London that build and fit bespoke furniture such as wardrobes in bedrooms or storage & entertainment units in reception rooms.

Shariful said...

Có nhiều cách đánh số đề miền Trung khác nhau cho người chơi chọn lựa. Để mang lại hiệu quả cao nhất, bạn không nên bỏ qua những phương pháp dưới đây. so de mien trung

Black Ocean said...

This blog is truly useful to convey overhauled instructive undertakings over web which is truly examination. I discovered one fruitful case of this truth through this blog. I will utilize such data now. Jewelry

Imagescutout said...

Hi, Very good article on Latency & Human Response Time in current and future games,
Thanks for sharing, keep up the good work.


Photoshop Clipping Path | Web Images Optimization | Images Background Remove | Natural Drop Shadow | Raster to Vector Conversion | Contact Us

Pixax said...

there are many android app for home security but guarding vision for PC is best of them

chumsrubbish said...

Thanks for this post. It proves very informative for me. Great post to read. Keep blogging.

If you are looking for the top security companies in London that provide its customer with remarkable security services. Check out this site for security services and plumbing and heating supply

Unknown said...

beauty tips
best beauty tips
buy beauty products
beauty tips
beauty tricks

Unknown said...

buy beauty products
beauty tips
beauty tricks
best beauty tips
buy beauty products
best beauty tips

Unknown said...

best beauty tip
best beauty tips
buy beauty products
beauty tips
beauty tricks
best beauty tips
buy beauty products

lakeyards said...

emaraatbusinessconsultant.com
emaraatbusinessconsultant.com
emaraatbusinessconsultant.com
emaraatbusinessconsultant.com
emaraatbusinessconsultant.com
emaraatbusinessconsultant.com

Unknown said...

boy shoes
buy shoes
buy best shoes
buy shoes online
buy best shoes online
shoes
shoe

the worthy stars said...

best shoes
girls shoes
boys shoes
girl shoes
boy shoes
buy shoes
buy best shoes

Unknown said...

buy shoes online
buy best shoes online
shoes
shoe
best shoes
girls shoes
boys shoes

Unknown said...

buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams

Unknown said...

shoes
shoeslylo
men shoes
shoes for men
buy shoes for men
buy online men shoes
buy best online men shoes
shoe for men

Unknown said...

shoes
shoeslylo
men shoes
shoes for men
buy shoes for men
buy online men shoes
buy best online men shoes
shoe for men

Unknown said...

buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams
buff streams

OMG Gamerz said...

thanks for sharing love this post best gaming mouse

Joker Slot 303 said...

Joker123 Online Game Most Popular in the World Smart Phone gaming For that, for those who are interested in cheap online deposit slots, here is the place

Joker123
Agen Joker123
Situs Joker123
Joker123 Deposit Pulsa

Unknown said...

media agency
media
advertising agency
media advertising agency
media agency
media
advertising agency
media advertising agency

Unknown said...

media agency
media
advertising agency
media advertising agency
media agency
media
advertising agency
media advertising agency

Chams Clearance London said...

It's really a nice and useful piece of information. I am satisfied that you shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

We carry out all the necessary Single Story Side Extension works required in any project that we undertake. This includes new installations, extensions or alterations of existing systems, or repairs and servicing. We provide a reliable, high-quality, and most importantly, competitive service.

the worthy stars said...

media agency
media
advertising agency
media advertising agency
media agency
media
advertising agency
media advertising agency

Lovin said...

game news update for gaming info

Mastah said...

Kumpulan Script Skin Mobile Legends Patch Terbaru – Halo sahabat-sahabat semuanya, pada kesempatan kali ini admin akan membagikan Script Mobile Legends skin pahlawan Mobile Legends terbaru yang mungkin mampu kalian coba. Dalam artikel ini admin akan menyediakan banyak link download script skin mulai dari skin pendekar epic hingga legends akan ada di bawah ini.

Bagi kalian yang ingin menggunakan skin keren namun belum mempunyai cukup diamond untuk membelinya maka solusi terbaiknya yaitu dengan menggunakan cheat skin hero Mobile Legends ini. Tampilan skin akan sama persis dengan aslinya bahkan mungkin tidak ada perbedaan sama sekali.

Admin said...

Cheat Semua Skin Mobile Legends Patch Terbaru
Kumpulan Script Skin Hero Mobile Legends Terlengkap Patch Terbaru
Kumpulan Kode Redeem Mobile Legends Terbaru 2020
Script Drone View Mobile Legends Update Patch Terbaru 2020
Build Item Zhask Tersakit Mobile Legends Jony Mirip Turret
Build Gear Popol Dan Kupa Tersakit Over Power Savage
Build Item Valir Tersakit Mobile Legends Gear Top Global
Build Cecilion Tersakit Mobile Legends Full Damage Savage
Build Pharsa Tersakit Dan Terbaru Di Mobile Legends
Build Nana Mobile Legends Tersakit Dan Baru Rrq Lemon

Drama Korea said...

Moto Racer 3 Gold Edition the complete range of motorbike sport. Freestyling, supercross, motocross, trailing, Grand Prix and street racing
Dozens of bikes from mopeds to Superbikes and circuits from around the world
Race round GP tracks like Suzuka or Barcelona, tear your way through rush hour traffic through central Paris or pull stunts in front of thousands in the Stade de France
Tons of unlockable bonuses keep the gameplay coming, with new circuits, bikes and riders to discover.

Drama Korea said...

Moto Racer 3 Gold Edition the complete range of motorbike sport. Freestyling, supercross, motocross, trailing, Grand Prix and street racing
Dozens of bikes from mopeds to Superbikes and circuits from around the world
Race round GP tracks like Suzuka or Barcelona, tear your way through rush hour traffic through central Paris or pull stunts in front of thousands in the Stade de France
Tons of unlockable bonuses keep the gameplay coming, with new circuits, bikes and riders to discover.

Mahasiswa Zombie said...

Windows 10Xcan runs android apps without an Emulator

Esports Indonesia said...

For those of you who are looking for Mobile / PC esports tournaments such as MLBB, PUBG, FF, CODM, CSGO etc. You can visit the link that we include below because, the prizes offered are very large, and only the latest Android games are contested so, make sure you join this tournament guys.

Mikel lee said...

such a great post I like it very much keep it up.
lip gloss box with window
Kraft boxes Canada

Jaff Parker said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Chris Michael said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Pooja Singh said...


Good web site you have here.. It's difficult to find high-quality writing like yours these days.
I honestly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!! Read It Also: "https://techonuz.com/toss-the-turtle-hacked-apk-download-from-here/"

Chris Michael said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
vivikhapnoi said...

I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!

vé máy bay từ tphcm đi đài bắc

vé máy bay hà nội cao hùng

vé máy bay đi bắc kinh trung quốc

vé máy bay giá rẻ đi quảng châu

thời gian bay từ việt nam sang thượng hải

Custom Packaging Solution said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

All details you describe in your blog post about Gable box is very informative for me. Customboxesu provides Gable box with suitable price.

Jaff Parker said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Chris Michael said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Cindy said...

Informasi Keluaran SGP

Data SGP Komplit

SGP Hari Ini Terupdate

Result Terpercaya Pasaran Singapura

Cara Mendapatkan Hadiah Dari Nomor SGP

Abu fateh said...

I read the post it is a very good post . Its really nice post. I hope its useful to everyone. Check me here which is an spa product selling site.

Chris Michael said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Clipping Path said...

this is the best post ever

Custom Packaging Solution said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ashim SD said...

air purifier for traffic pollution

Tutor Visit said...

Good! Tutor Visit is the perfect place if you want to get help from the Best Online Geometry Tutor.

Mary Davies said...

We offer custom presentation boxes wholesale that give you full liberty of customizing the entire packaging at every step. Packaging is the first thing a customer notices. IBEX Packaging is one of the most trusted custom packaging companies in the USA.

Knowledge Uplift said...

Amazing! Start today and become an expert in days with Knowledge Uplift best CCNA online training.

Information hub said...

Bei stark bis extrem inkrustierten, das heißt verengten Rohrleitungen, kommt die hydro­mecha­nische Rohrreinigung zum Einsatz. Auch hierbei verwenden die Fach­leute von Kuchler Service weder Säuren, Laugen noch um­welt­be­lastende Spül­mittel. Und den­noch er­rei­chen sie zügig das Ziel: eine saubere Leitung – durch eine rund­herum saubere Arbeit, die mehr Effizienz bringt als Kosten nach sich zieht.

Rohrreinigung deggendorf

kingsbola said...

Hello welcome. We are from tristed online gambling site agent who have always provided some of the best and most trusted gambling sites for all of you. Here I will again recommend some online gambling sites that are very worthy for you to try. Because I am sure you will be satisfied if you join this online gambling site that I would recommend.

If you want to join the site I will recommend to you. please just enter at a collection of the best and most trusted online gambling sites

after you click on the link earlier then you will automatically go to my website page. This website provides several qq or online poker gambling sites, of course, with the best quality. And even already have a trusted predicate.

So what are you waiting for and want to find another one. If the best is in front of you. Please join us immediately. We will always guarantee your satisfaction. And we believe you are unlikely to be disappointed. Because many have succeeded in getting what they want. Maybe you yourself understand what I'm talking about, okay?

Visit Here said...

Car tracker in Bahawalpur
When was running invented
Chiclet teeth
833 Area code
cob today

Chris Patel said...

Professionelle Schädlingsbekämpfung und Kammerjäger in München und Umgebung sowie in allen Teilen der Stadt und Umgebung.
Wir bekämpfen kompetent, effektiv und vor allem diskret jede Art von Schädlingsbefall.
Wir von Kammerjäger München 24 sind Kammerjäger München.Schädlingsbekämpfung München

elie said...

Hello welcome. We are from  tristed online gambling site agent   who have always provided some of the best and most trusted gambling sites for all of you. Here I will again recommend some online gambling sites that are very worthy for you to try. Because I am sure you will be satisfied if you join this online gambling site that I would recommend.

If you want to join the site I will recommend to you. please just enter at a collection of the best and most trusted online gambling sites

after you click on the link earlier then you will automatically go to my website page. This website provides several qq or online poker gambling sites, of course, with the best quality. And even already have a trusted predicate.

elie said...

Hello welcome. We are from  tristed online gambling site agent   who have always provided some of the best and most trusted gambling sites for all of you. Here I will again recommend some online gambling sites that are very worthy for you to try. Because I am sure you will be satisfied if you join this online gambling site that I would recommend.

If you want to join the site I will recommend to you. please just enter at a collection of the best and most trusted online gambling sites

after you click on the link earlier then you will automatically go to my website page. This website provides several qq or online poker gambling sites, of course, with the best quality. And even already have a trusted predicate.

David Smith said...

Superb post indeed. Kindly share the Best Laptops to play Sims 4 in your next post because my friends are looking to buy in bulk.

Best Quran Teaching said...

Good! BQT offers UK online quran classes on a flexible schedule 24/7.

ahmet caglar said...

Nice blog thank youu


fivem server kirala unturned sunucu kurma fivem sunucu satın al minecraft vds kirala en ucuz mta sunucusu satın al

agen said...

this site is very good and very interesting visit also site
daftar situs judi idn poker online terpercaya, link alternatif idn poker , asialive888

ahmet caglar said...

Thank youuu for blog nice post

bireysel hosting
wordpress hosting
ucuz reseller hosting kiralama

mta sunucu kiralama
fivem sunucu kiralama
rust sunucu kiralama
minecraft sunucu kiralama
unturned sunucu kiralama

Tutor Visit said...

Wonderful! If you want to Learn IT Online then Tutor Visit is the best option.

durbannetworker.com said...

Hello welcome. We are from  tristed online gambling site agent   who have always provided some of the best and most trusted gambling sites for all of you. Here I will again recommend some online gambling sites that are very worthy for you to try. Because I am sure you will be satisfied if you join this online gambling site that I would recommend.

If you want to join the site I will recommend to you. please just enter at a collection of the best and most trusted online gambling sites

after you click on the link earlier then you will automatically go to my website page. This website provides several qq or online poker gambling sites, of course, with the best quality. And even already have a trusted predicate

durbannetworker.com said...

Hello welcome. We are from  tristed online gambling site agent   who have always provided some of the best and most trusted gambling sites for all of you. Here I will again recommend some online gambling sites that are very worthy for you to try. Because I am sure you will be satisfied if you join this online gambling site that I would recommend.

If you want to join the site I will recommend to you. please just enter at a collection of the best and most trusted online gambling sites

after you click on the link earlier then you will automatically go to my website page. This website provides several qq or online poker gambling sites, of course, with the best quality. And even already have a trusted predicate

kopianhela07 said...

Hello welcome. We are from  tristed online gambling site agent   who have always provided some of the best and most trusted gambling sites for all of you. Here I will again recommend some online gambling sites that are very worthy for you to try. Because I am sure you will be satisfied if you join this online gambling site that I would recommend.

If you want to join the site I will recommend to you. please just enter at a collection of the best and most trusted online gambling sites

after you click on the link earlier then you will automatically go to my website page. This website provides several qq or online poker gambling sites, of course, with the best quality. And even already have a trusted predicate

unknow said...

Thanks for sharing an interesting and very useful blog. I appreciate your efforts. Click here

hyper said...

expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert

hyper said...

expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert
expert

agen said...

One of the miracles of the Internet with modern technology There are Sophisticated tools That allow us to Identify Potential Customers and Get Them to come to our web sites Now we can combine the thesis of Internet marketing tools with tried and true models That have worked in the trap pragmatic4d

Kucing Techno said...

Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55

Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55

Kucing Techno said...

Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55

Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55

Kucing Techno said...

Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55

Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55
Bandar55

Freedom said...


liga788
bandar55

malik said...

The best online casino for us, however, remains the Tropezia Palace. The latter has been owned since 2011 by the giant in the field. https://www.casinoonline-fr.com/

Hannamitra said...

https://images.google.co.ve/url?sa=t&url=https://www.hannamitragroup.com/
https://maps.google.ee/url?sa=t&url=https://www.hannamitragroup.com/
https://maps.google.si/url?sa=t&url=https://www.hannamitragroup.com/
https://images.google.com.ec/url?sa=t&url=https://www.hannamitragroup.com/
https://images.google.lv/url?sa=t&url=https://www.hannamitragroup.com/

ghost mannequin photo editing service said...

That’s a really informative article, I am very much inspired. Your tutorial helps me as like my mentor, i am looking forward to more informative article form you.greenteaneko

Eugene Bryant said...

Thank you for sharing such a wonderful article. I love it. To get best quality affordable Office Furniture please https://www.corporateofficeint.com/

Janny said...

UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir
UsahaAir

Anonymous said...

BIG THANKS INFORMATION, VERY GRATE UR ARTICLE..

slot online terbaik
agen slot online

hanna11 said...

BIG THANKS UR ARTICLE SIR, Please Visit Back...

judi bola online
slot online terpercaya

Simone Watson said...

Blog is amazing!! You have mentioned very thoughtful information. Digital rights management software is designed to create balance between content protection and ease of use, contact Video Multi-DRM Solution providers now.

ahmet caglar said...

Wordpress hosting kiralama
sanal sunucu kiralama
vds kiralama
bireysel hosting
vps satın al


Nice blog thank youu

rabekahmarshall said...

I feel extremely cheerful to have seen your post. I found the most beautiful and fascinating one. I am really extremely glad to visit your post.
buy dissertation is the best writing platform online that provides the best writing services. If you are interested do check it. It will be very helpful for your blogs.
Thanks!

Visit Here said...

Training service provider in united arab emirates for NDT level 2 course, welding course dubai, and QC Welding inspection training for oil and gas industry, Chemical and industrial and marine service companies.

Best Quran Teaching said...

Great! BQT offers online Quran classes by certified male and female tutors.

Steve said...

I saw your post you are doing such great work. Now I am telling you about a business. I have offered all of you Packaging for Lip gloss with free shipping. We are working in the USA but we are delivered over solution throughout the world. We also offer wholesale discounts as well.
cosmetic boxes

Ultra Tec UAE said...

Pretty good post. I just upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Anyway, I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info. Water Filter UAE and
Containerized Sea Water RO Plants

Chris Patel said...

lms in banking it’s important that your company uses a learning management system with features that will help you build engaging modules.
With SeekLMS,
lms in banking


Helge Erik said...


Thanks for thinking of it. That’s been true on my blog as well.


useful

Helge Erik said...

This is interesting Hope you enjoy it once you finally give it a try
grey


Thanks for sharing such an amazing list of blog
smallville


Thank you so much for the thoughtful comment here, I’m totally with you
black

Steven Brian said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Elise Edward said...

You article is very imformative
"Latency & Human Response Time in current and future games"
Regards :puffshaven

Ratana said...

I really appreciate your professional approach.These are pieces of very useful information that will be of great use for me in future.
របៀបលេង BACCARAT ONLINE

Techboyi said...

This is such a zealous ingeniousness that you are providing and you utilize it absent for inexact. I know sight blog that understand the treasure. Im glad to somebody initiate this instal as its such an intriguing one! I am e'er on the watchman for wellborn posts and articles so i assume im lucky to feature constitute this! I wish you testament
be adding statesman in the early parts of a computer.

Unknown said...

I love your posts and everything looks wonderful. I love your idea thanks for sharing.
Play Baccarat Online

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

This is very educational content and written well for a change. It's nice to see that some people still understand how to write a quality post.!
អ្វីជា​ Baccarat​

Unknown said...

This article is very interesting and gives a little information and don't forget to visit the site thank you.
online poker

makanyuk said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

The best article sir, I hope you become a great writer

gila138

Unknown said...

If you like play casino online with the best quality and service visit
live casino

Unknown said...

getting your website the growing and interesting to read. I have much to learn from you. thank you
Dragon Tiger

Unknown said...

This article is very interesting and gives a little information and don't forget to visit the site thank you.
ស្លតកាស៊ីណូអនឡាញ​​

Unknown said...

The best article sir, I hope you become a great writer

depo slot pulsa

etutorworld said...

online geometry tutoring.

Unknown said...

I really admire your writing, I hope you are always healthy GBU

judi slot pulsa

Kinslee Fink said...

Mein Schlüsseldienst Ingolstadt gesucht? Wir öffnen zum günstigen Festpreis ohne versteckte Kosten. Freundlich, fair und transparent. Schlüsseldienst Ingolstadt

Kinslee Fink said...

We are one of the leading car tracker pakistan company. No matter if it is day or night, you can rest assured because of our 24/7 availability.

TheVute said...

hi Kansas City offers a variety of entertainment and activities for all ages if you want to play and enjoy casino games visit my website Best Casinos in Kansas with Complete Guide

Josef56 said...

Le joli site contient vraiment des choses ici, mais si vous voulez convertir un fichier dans n'importe quel format, voici un site appelé fusionnerPDF Le format est pratique pour enregistrer des fichiers qui ne nécessitent pas d'édition mais qui sont faciles à imprimer et à partager. Si vous avez tendance à modifier un fichier protégé par copyright pour cela, consultez ce site fusionner en PDF

Kinslee Fink said...

At HeatStrokeCycle, we provide top rated electric scooters reviews, buying guides, comparisons, and top notch how-to guides. Visit here.
https://heatstrokecycle.com/reviews/yume-y10-review/

Kinslee Fink said...

We are providing Payroll tax,Irs tax form,Profit and loss Statement,Sba loan,Paystub,Balance sheet,Financial statement,Sba ppp which is calculated by totaling all of a business's revenue sources and subtracting from that all the business's expenses that are related to revenue. Visit here Profit and loss Statement

Linda Martin said...

Obrigado por este site. Eu aprecio seu trabalho. muito bom eu tenho um site que muda sua fonte no Insta, Facebook, Snapchat, e outras redes sociais se você quiser mudar seu nome de usuário Visite moldes de letras

Faisal Rao said...

It is almost impossible to find anywhere today where we are not being bombarded by multiple harmful EMF fields. This is possibly the most dangerous threat to our health today and the potential plague of the 21st century. Sources include cell phones, cell phone towers, wifi networks, auto GPS devices, toll booth scanners, airport security scanners, grocery store check-out scanners, high wires, all electrical wiring, and electrical devices such as computers, cars, phones, TVs, and more.

for more details Visit here https://www.innerharmonywellness.com/

Unknown said...

Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging Apkdownload.com

Anjali Sharma said...

Get the list of best Teen Patti Software Providers. We provide the best Teen Patti Software with high UX/UI designs at minimum prices.

Eliza said...

It was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, thanks for sharing post It really admire your writing skill, hey, I'm also a gamer and here I'm sharing something like that so click on desmume

Michel lio said...

This is very interesting blog and very helpful for newcomers, , I really like it. Keep working and thanks for sharing this great information. I am a gamer and here is something interesting for you. You may click on ultimate spider man game hope you like it.

Ufa88kh said...

Thanks for sharing this informative post. It's very helpful. Keep it up!
wordpress
blogspot
youtube
មាន់ជល់

Mahir Company said...

If your air conditioner not working properly Mahir Company provides complete ac services in Lahore that include AC Installation in Lahore, ac repair in Lahore and Ac master services in Lahore. You can call us at +923096661919 for more details.

Norrain said...

If you are looking for the best sulphate free shampoo in Pakistan so you must visit this website sulfate free Shampoo in Pakistan

raju said...

wordpress website design agency in united states Need professional WordPress Web Design Services? We're experts in developing attractive mobile-friendly WordPress websites for businesses. Contact us today!

Asif Iftekhar said...

I loved your post. wonderful.
jewelry retouching tutorial

ppsc papers said...

This is valuable information, I really appreciate your hard wok. You can also check fjackets.com and appreciate us too

top series said...

Very informative and valuable content you have on this site that is what I exactly looking for Thanks for sharing this interesting content. I like it very much.  Also visit Healthfatal.com for latest updates.

Tobacco Stock said...

"Get your roll on with Tobacco Stock's premium Blunt Wraps - perfect for your next waxing session. Order now and experience the ultimate smoking experience!"

Mohsiin blogs said...

At Hail EST, we want to provide you with as much east to understand information as possible. This includes why you should use Hail Damage

Ken Miles said...

Delving into the fascinating realm of latency in gaming mirrors the precision needed when selecting teething sticks for babies. Both emphasize optimal response times for a seamless experience.

Vicky White said...

In the intricate dance of gaming, latency mirrors the soul of user interaction. Within our web development company in florida, we meticulously sculpt solutions, ensuring minimal latency for an unparalleled, immersive gaming odyssey

Followers